Files
redefined-designs/.gitea/workflows/sonarqube.yml
T
bermudalambandClaude Opus 5 25661ea620 fix(ci): stop pull request scans overwriting the dashboard's picture of main (#197)
SonarQube Community has no branch analysis. Every scan published under a project key replaces that project's single analysis, whatever revision it came from — so each pull request, and each push to one, overwrote the dashboard's analysis of main with the branch. The new-code period, the gate result, the coverage percentages and the hotspot list then all described whatever was scanned last, with nothing on the dashboard saying which revision that was. A gate that went green on a feature branch read exactly like a gate that went green on main.

It was caught only by luck: #180's hotspots reported line numbers that landed on a comment and a blank line in main, which is the kind of nonsense a person notices. Everything else it misreported would have looked fine.

scripts/scan-local.sh has always refused to do this, defaulting to a scratch key, and its header says why in as many words. CI walked into the hazard that script guards against. Now the two tell the same story.

The suites still run on pull requests, which is where their value is — only publishing is restricted. The measures report is skipped alongside the scan, because with nothing published it would print main's numbers into a pull request's log, which is noise at best and misread as the branch's own at worst.

A test asserts both steps carry the restriction and that the three suites do not, because the failure leaves no trace and the `if:` is one line for somebody to drop.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-09-02 08:37:29 -05:00

298 lines
13 KiB
YAML
Executable File

name: SonarQube Analysis
# The only workflow that runs the test suites. tests.yml used to run the unit
# and end-to-end suites as well, on identical triggers, so every pull request
# installed, migrated, built, started the backend and ran the whole end-to-end
# suite twice. With one runner the second copy did not run in parallel, it
# queued. It was deleted and its two summarize steps folded in here. See #123.
#
# Note that the integration suite DOES run here, on every push and pull request,
# despite backend-integration.yml describing it as manual. That quarantine only
# ever applied to tests.yml. It is survivable here because test:integration:cov
# passes --forceExit, which papers over the post-run hang, and because of the
# timeout below.
on:
push:
branches: [main]
pull_request:
types: [opened, synchronize, reopened]
workflow_dispatch:
jobs:
sonarqube:
runs-on: ubuntu-latest
# The scanner needs every coverage report in one workspace, so the suites run
# here rather than being passed between jobs as artifacts. That makes this the
# long job. The timeout is a stop, not a budget: the integration suite has
# hung after completing before (see backend-integration.yml) and cost three
# hours of runner time.
timeout-minutes: 30
services:
postgres:
image: postgres:16
env:
POSTGRES_USER: redefined_test
POSTGRES_PASSWORD: redefined_test
POSTGRES_DB: redefined_test
options: >-
--health-cmd "pg_isready -U redefined_test"
--health-interval 5s
--health-timeout 5s
--health-retries 10
env:
# Consumed by the integration suite's setup files.
TEST_PGHOST: postgres
TEST_PGPORT: 5432
TEST_PGUSER: redefined_test
TEST_PGPASSWORD: redefined_test
TEST_PGDATABASE: redefined_test
# Consumed by the backend process the end-to-end run drives.
PGHOST: postgres
PGPORT: 5432
PGUSER: redefined_test
PGPASSWORD: redefined_test
PGDATABASE: redefined_test
PORT: 3000
DEMO_MODE: 'true'
UPLOADS_DIR: /tmp/redefined-uploads
# NODE_ENV is deliberately unset: `npm install` omits devDependencies when
# NODE_ENV=production, which strips tsc/vite/@playwright/test and breaks the
# build. It would also flip the session cookie to Secure, which the e2e run
# serves over plain http.
steps:
- name: Checkout
uses: actions/checkout@v4
with:
fetch-depth: 0
- name: Setup Node
uses: actions/setup-node@v4
with:
node-version: '20'
- name: Install backend deps
run: npm install
working-directory: backend
- name: Install frontend deps
run: npm install
working-directory: frontend
- name: TypeScript build check (backend)
run: npm run build
working-directory: backend
- name: TypeScript build check (frontend)
run: npm run build
working-directory: frontend
# The frontend's build was the only thing this workspace ran, so the unit
# suite #188 added over the filter dimensions was run by nothing but the
# author's terminal. A suite CI never runs decays into a record of what
# the code used to do, and its value is highest exactly here: chips() is
# pure, and the end-to-end run reaches it only through a browser.
#
# Guarded and named in the gate like every suite: a failing test should
# fail the job at the end, not abort it and take the scan with it.
- name: Frontend unit tests
id: frontend_unit
continue-on-error: true
run: npm run test:unit
working-directory: frontend
- name: Check the Sonar tsconfig has not drifted
run: node scripts/check-sonar-tsconfig.js
- name: Run migrations
run: node migrate.js up
working-directory: backend
# --json/--outputFile appended rather than baked into the script: the
# coverage run and the results file are wanted together here, and nowhere
# else. summarize-jest.js below reads that file.
- name: Backend unit tests with coverage
id: unit
continue-on-error: true
run: npm run test:unit:cov -- --json --outputFile=unit-results.json
working-directory: backend
# Covers everything in src/routes, which the unit suite does not touch —
# without this the backend reports around 11% rather than the ~73% it
# actually has.
#
# Guarded like the other two suites. It was the only one that was not, so
# it was the only one whose failure aborted the job — taking the scan, the
# end-to-end run and the coverage merge with it. That is what #154 has
# cost on every push since it started: not a degraded analysis, none at
# all. See #174.
- name: Backend integration tests with coverage
id: integration
continue-on-error: true
run: npm run test:integration:cov -- --json --outputFile=integration-results.json
working-directory: backend
# Guarded because the scan does not depend on it. A backend that will not
# start fails the end-to-end run below on its own, and the gate records
# both — there is no reason for it to also cost the analysis.
- name: Start backend for the end-to-end run
id: backend
continue-on-error: true
run: |
mkdir -p /tmp/redefined-uploads
node dist/server.js > /tmp/backend.log 2>&1 &
for i in $(seq 1 30); do
if node -e "require('http').get('http://localhost:3000/api/config', r => process.exit(r.statusCode === 200 ? 0 : 1)).on('error', () => process.exit(1))"; then
echo "Backend ready after ${i}s"
exit 0
fi
sleep 1
done
echo "Backend did not become ready within 30s:"
cat /tmp/backend.log
exit 1
working-directory: backend
# A network fetch, and so the least interesting way to lose an analysis.
- name: Install Playwright browsers
id: browsers
continue-on-error: true
run: npx playwright install --with-deps chromium
working-directory: frontend
# Runs against an istanbul-instrumented dev server, which is what produces
# window.__coverage__ for the fixture to collect.
- name: Frontend end-to-end tests with coverage
id: e2e
continue-on-error: true
env:
PLAYWRIGHT_JSON_OUTPUT_NAME: playwright-results.json
# list as well as json, so the log still shows which test failed rather
# than only a file nobody reads until the summary step.
run: npm run test:e2e:cov -- --reporter=list,json
working-directory: frontend
# Keyed off the step outcome rather than failure(). continue-on-error above
# means the job is not in a failed state at this point, so failure() would
# never fire and the log that explains an end-to-end failure would go
# unprinted precisely when it is wanted.
- name: Backend log
if: steps.e2e.outcome == 'failure' || steps.backend.outcome == 'failure'
run: cat /tmp/backend.log
# Fails when nothing was collected rather than writing an empty report. An
# uninstrumented dev server lets every test pass while gathering nothing,
# and the resulting 0% reads as "the tests stopped covering things".
- name: Merge frontend coverage
id: coverage
continue-on-error: true
run: npm run coverage:report
working-directory: frontend
# Guarded so that a scanner error does not take the summaries below with
# it. The gate still records it, so a failed scan fails the job.
#
# If a coverage report is missing — the end-to-end run collecting nothing,
# say — this scans anyway and SonarQube reports those files as uncovered,
# which reads as a regression rather than as a missing input. Accepted:
# jest still writes coverage for a suite whose tests fail, so the failure
# actually occurring produces all three reports; there is no
# sonar.qualitygate.wait, so a degraded run marks the dashboard and is
# overwritten by the next good one rather than blocking anything; and the
# job fails regardless, so no run in this state reads as clean.
# Not on pull requests. SonarQube Community has no branch analysis: every
# scan published under a project key replaces that project's single
# analysis, whatever revision it came from. So a pull request scan
# overwrote the dashboard's picture of main with the branch, silently, and
# the new-code period, gate result, coverage and hotspot list then all
# described whatever was scanned last with nothing saying which revision
# that was. #197 caught it in the act — the dashboard describing a feature
# branch while reporting hotspot line numbers that landed on a blank line
# in main.
#
# scripts/scan-local.sh already refuses to do this, defaulting to a
# scratch key for exactly this reason. CI walked into the hazard that
# script guards against; now the two tell the same story.
#
# The suites above still run on pull requests, which is where their value
# is. Only publishing is restricted.
- name: SonarQube Scan
id: scan
if: github.event_name != 'pull_request'
continue-on-error: true
uses: sonarsource/sonarqube-scan-action@v4
env:
SONAR_HOST_URL: ${{ secrets.SONAR_HOST_URL }}
SONAR_TOKEN: ${{ secrets.SONAR_TOKEN }}
# Readable pass and fail counts, which the raw jest and Playwright output
# does not give at a glance. Both run with if: always() so a failing suite
# is still summarised — which is the case they exist for.
- name: Summarize unit tests
if: always()
run: node scripts/summarize-jest.js backend/unit-results.json "Backend Unit Test"
# The suite this workflow has been failing on for weeks, and the only one
# that had no summary — so it presented as 36 assertion errors about
# categories and price filters rather than as a count. #154 records how
# expensive that misdirection was to read.
- name: Summarize integration tests
if: always()
run: node scripts/summarize-jest.js backend/integration-results.json "Backend Integration Test"
- name: Summarize end-to-end tests
if: always()
run: node scripts/summarize-playwright.js frontend/playwright-results.json
# The measures, printed into the log because that is the only place this
# project can read them. SonarQube 9.9 Community has no Bearer auth, so the
# official MCP cannot connect, and the host is a CI secret — so security
# hotspots, duplication, debt and coverage lived solely on a dashboard, and
# "reduce the debt" was an instruction nobody could act on without opening a
# browser. The scanner masks the URL and token; the measures are not secret.
#
# Deliberately not guarded with continue-on-error. The script exits 0 on
# every path, so it cannot fail the job anyway, and guarding it would
# oblige it to appear in the gate below — which exists to fail the job,
# the opposite of what a report should do. See #261.
# Skipped alongside the scan on pull requests. With nothing published, this
# would report main's numbers under a pull request's log, which is noise
# at best and misread as the branch's own at worst.
- name: Report SonarQube measures
if: always() && github.event_name != 'pull_request'
env:
SONAR_HOST_URL: ${{ secrets.SONAR_HOST_URL }}
SONAR_TOKEN: ${{ secrets.SONAR_TOKEN }}
run: node scripts/summarize-sonar.js
# Last, so a failing step still produces coverage, a scan and every
# summary first. Without this step continue-on-error above would turn a
# failing suite into a passing job, which is the one way this change could
# do real damage.
#
# Every guarded step is listed. That is the invariant — a step carrying
# continue-on-error and missing from here cannot fail the job at all — and
# tests/unit/workflowGate.test.ts asserts it, because the integration
# suite going unlisted is exactly how #174 happened.
#
# always() is load-bearing. A step whose `if:` omits it still implicitly
# requires every previous step to have succeeded, so this was skipped in
# exactly the case it exists for: the summarise step above used to exit 1
# on a failing suite, which failed the job first and left this gate as dead
# code. The job then reported its failure under a name that describes
# summarising rather than testing. The summarisers exit 0 now; this is what
# fails the run. See #142.
- name: Fail if any guarded step failed
if: >-
always() && (
steps.frontend_unit.outcome == 'failure' ||
steps.unit.outcome == 'failure' ||
steps.integration.outcome == 'failure' ||
steps.backend.outcome == 'failure' ||
steps.browsers.outcome == 'failure' ||
steps.e2e.outcome == 'failure' ||
steps.coverage.outcome == 'failure' ||
steps.scan.outcome == 'failure'
)
run: exit 1